Charter Arms Mag Pug .357 Review: Shiny, Small, Serious

by | Sep 24, 2025 | Firearms Review | 0 comments

By: Mike Hardesty

   The saying “A Fistful Of… (fill in the blank)” is still popular, long after the movie “A Fistful Of Dollars” came out in 1967. In this case, it’s warranted. This 21-ounce, 5-shot wheelgun is chambered in the attention-getting (on both sides of the muzzle) .357 Magnum. It gets my attention, for sure!

   Why in the world would anyone want a 21-ounce device that all but causes pain each time you use it? Because with any .357, you get to fire .38 Specials. You don’t have to keep abusing your body. Actually, this .357 shoots .38 Special better than its more muscular cousin, as we’ll see later.

   Here’s what it looks like… mug shots, so to speak. Shiny!

   If there ever was a “BBQ Gun”, this is it!

   Here’s an admission on my part… this gun was not sent to me for this review. I bought it after I reviewed it elsewhere, a good while ago. I like guns with some “bling”. (I also own plenty of plain, old black polymer pistols.) So, when I can, I’ll add something to the safe that has character, or is just a bit different. This qualifies.

   I also need to state upfront that these grips did not come with this gun. I bought them off the Charter Arms website. They are the G10 Backpacker Style grips, which retail for $48. The original grips are black, finger-groove rubber. They are boring. They DO help with recoil, but so do these, and they just look cooler.

   What initially attracted me to this gun was its finish. The highly polished stainless steel sure gets your attention. Two more features sealed the deal… the barrel is three inches, not two, and the rear sight is not the usual trough in the frame but is fully adjustable. That’s rare on a snubby. So, I bought it and have enjoyed owning it.

Why A Wheelgun?

   Younger shooters may not be overly familiar with revolvers, since the semi-auto has all but taken over the carry market in the last 30 or so years. But before Gaston Glock presented his wunderkind and the law enforcement world put the nail in the revolver’s coffin, revolvers were mainstay carry guns.

   For some of us, they still are. I own several revolvers and have a personal history with them. From .22s to my 8 ⅜” barreled S&W 629 .44 Magnum, I like to interact with them. I don’t know how many deer I’ve taken with that .44, or how many squirrels and other such small game have fallen to my .22s, .38s, and .357s over the decades.

   As an unrepentant handloader, I craft my centerfire loads in the mid-power range and have achieved decent results over the years.

Advantages Of The Revolver

   A revolver has some features that make it a viable carry gun. First, though, let’s address the elephant in the room… reloading speed. I can surely stuff a fresh magazine into my Springfield SA-35 High-Power tribute or my Echelon 4.0C faster than I can fill the chambers of any wheelgun I own. I admit that up front. But… how many rounds are enough? We’ve all heard the F.B.I. statistics that say a typical self-defense situation is resolved in 2.7 rounds, or whatever.

   I sometimes carry a S&W J-frame with a 5-shot cylinder. I typically will have one reload with me. Do I feel undergunned? Nope. I practice reloading and feel secure. I also practice shooting. Hitting what you aim at with a few rounds is more important than missing with many.

   Reliability. Revolvers are reliable. A good double-action (DA) revolver only requires another trigger press if the bullet under the hammer fails to exit the muzzle… no “tap-rack-bang”, no jerking a slide back. Granted, modern autoloaders are really reliable as a rule, but nothing is simpler than “pull the trigger again”. You can’t look at a magazine full of cartridges and pick out the ones that will possibly fail by sight… I wish you could. With a revolver, pull the trigger again if something fails.

   Easy To Teach. I am not a certified instructor – I respect those of you out there who are. However, I have shared some expertise over the years with new shooters who are aware that I have been shooting for several decades. Sometimes, they’ll formally ask me what handgun they should buy. Since I live in the boonies, I have a range in my backyard, so I’ll invite them over and we’ll shoot different guns. Nine times out of ten, semi-autos intimidate them. Training is the answer, but they want results now, so they gravitate toward a wheelgun.

   Easy To Load and Unload. Many folks I’ve spoken to have gotten confused just by loading (or unloading) a semi-automatic. They may pull the magazine out, but they usually will forget to check the chamber. I heard of an accidental discharge by a person the other day that made our local news. (Must’ve been a slow news day!) They’d forgotten to check the chamber and fired the “unloaded” gun accidentally. No one was hurt seriously – just a graze – but it could have been worse.

   With a DA revolver, loading involves opening the cylinder and inserting cartridges into the individual chambers. Unloading is accomplished by pressing the ejector rod to remove the empty cases. It’s easy to make a revolver safe… open the cylinder and remove the cartridges. There is no magazine to remove, nor a chamber to check. Newbies grasp this concept pretty easily.

   (Speaking of safety procedures, I remember Don Knotts’ character Barney on the old “Andy Griffith Show” who was allowed only one “bullet”… a single cartridge for his 4-inch .38 that he had to carry in his shirt pocket due to a few negligent discharges.

   What a great show… simpler times! “Opie” was actually younger than me…)

   Easy To Operate. The DA revolver is very easy to operate. Once loaded, simply align the front sight with the target and center it in the rear sight. A squeeze of the trigger launches the bullet downrange. There is one trigger pull to learn… the longer, DA pull that instructors will have you use. The lighter single-action trigger is great for targets or hunting, but most (if not all) defense training will require you to use the DA option.

   No Fetching Of Wayward Brass. The older I get, the more I appreciate not having to retrieve all those empties from the ground. ‘Nuff said.

   Please understand… I am not trying to get you to abandon your carry semi-auto and switch to a revolver! I am simply presenting some reasons that revolvers remain a viable choice for concealed carry and are not obsolete. I love my semis… I own several and use them. But I also own some wheelguns and use them, as well.

   Now that we have looked at why revolvers still matter, let’s look at the one in front of us today.

The Company

   Charter Arms is known for its affordable snub-nosed revolvers. The company has been in operation since 1964. Without going into detail, suffice it to say that the company has experienced its share of ups and downs, but now appears to be on an upward trajectory. They produce a wide range of different models in several calibers. I owned, back in the late ‘70s, the original .44 Bulldog:

   Chambered in .44 Special, this revolver gained notoriety in the mid-’70s as it was the tool of choice for the unhinged serial murderer, “Son of Sam” – A.K.A. Davide Berkowitz. If you are so inclined, you can read about his deeds here. I really liked that gun, and it served me well. Unfortunately, it put Charter Arms on the map for a nefarious reason, but they’ve overcome that now.

Today’s Gun

   Skipping up through time to today, we have a rather shiny, interesting revolver before us. Most modern revolvers that have earned the “snub nose” nickname are chambered in .38 Special. Contemporary ammunition technology has enhanced the effectiveness of this century-old cartridge. The round is nothing to sneeze at, for sure. The extra inch of barrel adds a touch more ballistic effectiveness, as well. Now, let’s factor in the fact that you can carry full-bore .357 Magnums in the gun. A new level is reached in terms of ballistics. Even though the .357 is not as effective out of a three-inch barrel as it is out of a six-incher, it still beats the .38 sll hollow. A 110- or a 125-grain JHP at 1100 fps is what you’ll get, and that ain’t nothin’ to sneeze at, as the saying goes.

   We see the Mag Pug’s profile above; now, let’s take a closer look at it.

   Note the full inderlug and engraving. In the shadow is written .357 MAG.

   (Red ramp courtesy of fingernail polish. I have since added TruGlo’s sight paint to my tool list).

   Rear sight up close. It adjusts for windage and elevation.

   The front sight and rear sight are both serrated to reduce glare. Charter Arms front sights all end in a sharp point, so I rounded it a bit to avoid extra holster wear.

   The G10 grip aids in recoil control. I was able to really tighten up my hold, using the finger grooves. That helped me to keep the front sight on target.

Specifications

• Series/Model: Mag Pug/73539
• Action: Single/Double
• Caliber: .357 Magnum
• Capacity: 5
• Weight: 21 oz.
• Sight: Rear adjustable, front ramp
• Grip Type: Standard
• Barrel Finish: Polished Stainless
• Frame Finish: Polished Stainless
• Barrel Length: 3″
• Overall Length: 7.32″
• Frame Size: Large
• Cylinder Finish: Polished Stainless Steel

One Carry Option

   I ran across this holster from Relentless Tactical.

   For $35, you can get a suede leather IWB holster that fits the gun, covers the trigger, and is Level I retention secure. This is just one option, of course, but I like leather. I was afraid that Kydex might damage the shiny finish. Anyway, I thought I would show it.

Target Time

   I gathered up some .38 Special loads and added a .357 Magnum load with trepidation. I have either owned or reviewed several lightweight .357s over the years, and I’m not kidding about my hand “talking” to me. It is not pleasant, touching off a full-charge .357 Magnum load in a gun that weighs about as much as a 20-ounce bottle of Sprite. I do not exaggerate – it hurts. Even with the original rubber grips, it’s not enjoyable.

   I shot a 158-grain JHP Mag Tech load and was able to hold tightly on the target, but the gun did not like it. I won’t waste your time by posting the target. I had different .357 ammo available, but to be honest, I wasn’t up to the abuse.

   Instead, here are a couple of 158-grain .38 targets. I placed the targets at 15 yards.

   Neither of these was bad, considering the short sight radius. To be honest, sometimes I don’t get the best results from snubbies, but these loads were encouraging. You could try several different .38 loads and find one that prints a decent group in the center of the target. These are two you could start with.

   But… it’s a .357, right? You could do the same with .357 ammo. Try a few different bullet weights to find the one that works best for you. If you decide that you are going to carry magnum loads, you could practice mostly with .38s, but you might end the shooting session with a cylinder or two of .357s to get familiar with the bullet point of impact and recoil.

Conclusion

   For those shooters who like to carry revolvers, Charter Arms is a definite option. The guns themselves have improved significantly in terms of quality compared to what they were in the ‘90s.

I have not had any problems with this or other review revolvers from Charter over the years. I think this gun might make a good carry option for revolver lovers. The reliability is there (in my experience with them), and they won’t break the bank. Want a different caliber? No sweat. I like the .44 Special, also… my next Charter will probably be of that persuasion.

   It isn’t an auto-loader, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing… Revolvers are resurgent in popularity. It might be fun to see why!

0 Comments

Latest Posts
Related Posts

ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST

   Sounds like a title to a song? Well, it is, released by “Dire Straits” in the 70s.    This is not about the song, although it was a good song.    Once again we focus on a trip west, through New Mexico and Arizona.    We made our arrangements to meet in Junction....

read more

THE WOKENESS AND DOWNFALL OF NASCAR

   I was going to lay off and stay away from politics one issue but really it all comes Full Circle and politics is always around and involved everywhere.    Nascar stock car racing is really the only sport that I like and enjoy anymore, All other sports have mucked...

read more

OUR FOOD SUPPLY IS BEING DESTROYED

   You do realize this is the first step in taking control? Besides all of this below, Thousands of cattle have supposedly died of high heat and about 10,000 supposedly died of Freezing to death, yes, All at once. How about how farmers are being told what they can and...

read more

America is Lost

   America is extremely lost right now and it needs to be found. This needs to be done before we go beyond the point of No Return. We are nearing in close to that right now. This whole globalist agenda put in place by Barack Obama starting back in 2008 was so in-depth...

read more

Yankee’s Ride

   Well, I did something I normally don’t do, I left in the rain. The kickstand was up at 10 am. I was on a mission, probably from God.    Headed east on Hwy 290 towards Fredericksburg, cruising through town. Stereo playing Bad Company, fits me. Ground Pounder Pipes...

read more

The State of Yesterday and Today

   I mentioned some of this a few issues back but deserves repeating. Barack Obama had a full 8 years of uninterrupted dismay to undercover and set the foundation for this nation as a Socialist and Globalist America, Hillary would then win the election and continue...

read more
Join Our Newsletter

Join Our Newsletter

Join Our Newsletter and Get the latest updates and info on exclusive events, Don't be left out! 

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Share This